Which mp3 player???? urgent help needed.?

Am buying my partner his birthday gift tonight (ive bought him two tshirts already) and want to get him an mp3 player. I was deliberating between a cheap ipod I saw but it was refurbished and a Phillips 2gb one from target which would have warranty.. since then I have found a “creative zen wav 2gb mp3 %26amp; video player with built in speakers” for $108.95 with 12 months manufacturers warranty. I don’t know what warranty the Phillips one had but its $119.00 and is 2gb also (without built in speakers)





So my question to you/- if you had the choice would you chose





- Phillips 2 GB MP3 player from Target (unsure of warranty, guessing 1yr manufacturers) $119.00


Or


- Creative Zen Wav 2GB MP3 %26amp; Video Player W/ In-Built Speakers $108.95





Thanks in advance for your answers. Please let me know which is better and why???

Which mp3 player???? urgent help needed.?
Creative Zen Wav 2GB MP3 %26amp; Video Player W/ In-Built Speakers $108.95 cheaper and more things in it